Paromita Das
GG News Bureau
New Delhi, 22nd Jan. On January 20, 2025, President Donald Trump announced a sweeping executive order aimed at ending birthright citizenship in the United States—a fundamental tenet of the nation’s immigration framework for over 150 years. The policy, effective February 19, 2025, denies automatic citizenship to children born on U.S. soil if their parents are undocumented or on temporary visas. While the executive order exempts those already naturalized or holding citizenship, its ramifications for immigrant communities, particularly Bharatiya-American families, are profound.
This bold move represents a seismic shift in U.S. immigration policy, drawing both widespread criticism and fervent support. It has reignited debates about constitutional interpretations, social inclusion, and the long-term impact on immigrant communities that have long relied on birthright citizenship as a cornerstone of their American dream.
The Historical Context and Scope of the Policy
Birthright citizenship, rooted in the 14th Amendment to the U.S. Constitution, has guaranteed citizenship to anyone born on American soil since its ratification in 1868. Trump’s executive order directly challenges this principle, proposing a narrower interpretation that ties citizenship to the legal status of a child’s parents.
Under the new policy, children born in the U.S. will only qualify for citizenship if at least one parent is a U.S. citizen, holds a green card, or serves in the U.S. military. This marks a significant departure from the long-held practice of unconditional birthright citizenship and extends the policy’s reach to include children of legal immigrants on temporary visas such as H-1B, F-1, or L-1.
Bharatiya-American Families: A Community in Limbo
The executive order has sent shockwaves through the Bharatiya-American community, which numbers approximately 5.4 million and constitutes 1.47% of the U.S. population. For many Bharatiya families, birthright citizenship has been a crucial lifeline, offering their U.S.-born children a pathway to stability, education, and opportunities.
Bharatiya families are disproportionately affected due to their reliance on employment-based temporary visas such as H-1B (for skilled professionals) and H-4 (for dependents). Many are already entangled in lengthy green card backlogs that can take decades to resolve. Previously, U.S.-born children could act as anchors, sponsoring their parents for permanent residency once they turned 21. With birthright citizenship eliminated, this option is off the table, leaving families vulnerable to prolonged legal and financial uncertainties.
Impact on Visa Holders and Birth Tourism
The policy’s implications extend beyond long-term immigrants to include temporary visitors and “birth tourists”—individuals who travel to the U.S. with the intent of giving birth to secure citizenship for their child. According to reports, Bharatiya and Mexicans constitute a significant portion of birth tourists. Trump’s policy aims to curtail this practice, targeting what his administration views as a loophole in the immigration system.
For visa holders—whether they are students, professionals, or tourists—the stakes are even higher. Children born to parents on temporary visas like F-1 (for academic students) or L-1 (for intra-company transfers) will no longer receive citizenship at birth, adding layers of complexity to their immigration status and future in the U.S.
Legal Challenges and Constitutional Questions
Unsurprisingly, the executive order has sparked immediate legal challenges. Advocacy groups such as the American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU) argue that the policy contradicts the 14th Amendment, which explicitly grants citizenship to all individuals born in the U.S. Legal experts anticipate that the Trump administration may push the issue to the Supreme Court, banking on the conservative majority to reinterpret the constitutional provision. Critics also emphasize that such drastic policy changes should be determined by Congress, not the executive branch, cautioning against the risks of unilateral action in reshaping foundational aspects of American society.
A Policy of Exclusion
Ending birthright citizenship is a deeply polarizing move that fundamentally reshapes the immigrant narrative in the United States. While proponents argue that it addresses abuses of the immigration system, the policy undermines core American values of inclusion and equality.
For Bharatiya families and other immigrant communities, this executive order symbolizes a shift away from opportunity and integration toward exclusion and uncertainty. Birthright citizenship has long provided a sense of belonging and stability to children of immigrants, enabling them to thrive as full members of society. Its removal risks creating a generation of children who, despite being born and raised in the U.S., may feel like perpetual outsiders.
The policy also disproportionately impacts skilled professionals on temporary visas, many of whom contribute significantly to the U.S. economy. By stripping their children of automatic citizenship, the executive order introduces barriers that could deter talent from seeking opportunities in the U.S., ultimately affecting the country’s competitiveness on the global stage.
A New Chapter in U.S. Immigration
Trump’s executive order to end birthright citizenship marks a watershed moment in America’s immigration policy, with far-reaching implications for millions of families. For Bharatiya-American communities, it represents a profound disruption to the pathways of opportunity and stability that have defined their journey in the U.S.
As the policy faces legal battles and potential Supreme Court scrutiny, its ultimate fate remains uncertain. However, its immediate impact is clear: a climate of anxiety and division that challenges the inclusivity and equality that have been hallmarks of American identity.
The broader question is whether the U.S. can balance the enforcement of immigration laws with its legacy as a nation of immigrants. In seeking to reshape this balance, the executive order sets the stage for a national debate that will shape the future of immigration, identity, and opportunity in America for generations to come.
The post Trump’s Move to End Birthright Citizenship: A Turning Point for Immigration in America appeared first on Global Governance News- Asia's First Bilingual News portal for Global News and Updates.
